There might be a rare illegal who in spite of being paid cash under the table went ahead and paid federal and state income tax on his earnings, and also registered for the Selective Service as required. If anyone can find them ---I wouldn't care if they got amnesty ---but none of the others.
However, it bothers me, that you want illegal immigrants to receive amnesty just because of a piece of paper. You seem to suggest that our existing law
may be circum-navigated just because of some work ethic. Yet the fact remains, even those that may have the piece of paper have lied to America and are outlaws for being here illegally.
It is ashame that some folks in America feel it is okay to allow outlaws into America thus further exascerbating our current problems.
Add not having used taxpayer subsidized health and welfare services and public education and we might have a deal..