[GussiedUp]

So you think that just because one of our guys got shot and killed, presumably after surrendering but maybe after engaging the enemy, we should today shoot all the captives in Gitmo?

We should have shot all those pigs at Gitmo before they ever arrived at Gitmo.

[rbmillerjr]

I agree, we should have killed them on the battlefield. Why we are using Psyops to get them to surrender - I'll never know. I would not be proactively seeking surrender from the scumbags........and I also think the best thing that can happen to Taliban Johnny, is that he get life and stay in prison where he is safe.

[ironman]

I agree it would have been better if we wiped them all out over in Talibanland, but the fact is we didn't. Now unfortunately we have to feed them and keep them locked up until their fate can be determined. I would hope the guards have shoot to kill orders if any try to escape or injur our guys.