If you advance a position and then purport to justify it then put up or shut up.
Monkeyshine and I, if there were any real disagreements, have been discussing the substance of his statements rather than what the Torah actually says
And yet you continued to parrot his version as if you didn't believe a word monkeyshine or the Jewish posters asserted. Is this your version of the "catch me if you can" argument?
What position have I advanced? Do you even know?
I haven't parroted anyone's version at all. In fact if you had any intellectual honesty you would have also noticed when I conceded a point to Monkeshine. But it appears as if you are more interested in creating disagreements where none exist.