[RightWhale]

America LOST the War of 1812

So the Redcoats burned DC to the ground. So what? No big deal. It wasn't much of a war anyway. Just a misunderstanding. Remember New Orleans.

[Poohbah]

Like I said, if England had not been distracted by Continental misadventures, we probably would have lost our independence--de facto if not de jure.

[Billthedrill]

So the Redcoats burned DC to the ground. So what? No big deal.

Yes, but they did some bad things too. I think.

Sure, they burned D.C. to the ground...but what have they done for us lately?

[John H K]

So the Redcoats burned DC to the ground. So what? No big deal. It wasn't much of a war anyway. Just a misunderstanding. Remember New Orleans.

The burning of DC was in retaliation for the American burning to the ground of York (the old name for Toronto.)

And the US failed in its primary objective, to conquer Canada. The stuff about protesting impressment of US sailors was merely a convenient excuse; the maritime states of New England that had the sailors being taken were OPPOSED to the war, while Western states supported it. The majority of the members of congress who voted for the war voted for it for the primary reason of capturing Canada.

All that most people know about the war comes from high school history textbooks, which are pretty crappy and sanitized.