Replies

What a bunch of anecdotal baloney.

Stinnett also authored another book you might like:

George Bush: His World War II Years

As for Day of Deceit, I've read it and his case is ironclad, bolstered throughout by recently declassified government documents.

Wait long enough, and the truth does come out.

Many people suspected the truth at the time, of course, but the war fever at the time made any expression of that truth seem unpatriotic. Sound familiar?

Well please quit trying to purposely misconstrue what I said. I was arguing that simply because someone is former military doesn’t mean they are always truthful and I cited how some say our government has knowledge of aliens. Secondly you aren’t proving anything, disputing anything, but you are merely relying on some deluded projection of inevitability.

I post once more: "Isn't it possible — just possible — that the majority of Americans are right and the dissidents are wrong? But there's nothing in the world of biology, zoology, or logic for that matter which says the sheep who wander out of the herd are any smarter than the ones who stay in it."

Stinnett also authored another book you might like:

I can post the names of dozens of books, all with "unclassified government documents", that "prove" that we never landed on the moon.

That doesn't prove anything though.

Oh, so knowledge of an impending event is what sets you off? Hey, I've got news for you, the Poles knew the Nazis were going to attack when there were 1.5 million German troops on their border. Does that make them culpable? I guess they asked for it then, huh? Obviously it was a result of a conspiracy between the Polish leadership and the Nazis. It must have been to benefit the wealthy Poles, you know the Polish aristocracy, the class of Poles which was completely exterminated within 6 weeks of Nazi occupation. Or perhaps it was "the Jews"? Yeah, they made out like bandits under the Nazis in Poland. Obviously another conspiracy.

Here's another comtemporary of the "Pearl Harbor: government complicity" reasoning: the French were already at war with Germany when the Panzers rolled thru the Ardennes and encircled them. "Guilty" as well? You remind me of the French police who rounded up retreating French soldiers at the train stations and executed them or the French peasants pitchforking downed Allied pilots because they "didn't stop" the Germans from strafing them.

Next time there's a crime in your neighborhood perhaps the police should come and arrest you. "Arrest Arator, he knows everything, therefore he was in on it".