[Roscoe]

Your analogy is a non sequitur.

No, it's right on the money.

[Liberal Classic]

MadameAxe wrote:
We're just "one-percenters", with no ability to have an effect on anything, right?

You replied:
Drunken drivers are probably less than 1% of the motorists on the road.

MadameAxe responded:
Your analogy is a non sequitur.

To which you replied:
No, it's right on the money.

No, that's a perfect example of a fallacy:

Dangerous drunk drivers comprise 1% of the population.
Libertarians are 1% of the population.
Therefore, Libertarians are dangerous.

Roscoe, just because drunk-divers and libertarians may comprise 1% of the population, it does not follow that libertarians and drunk drivers are the same one percent. (As an aside, I believe this is the fallacy of the undistributed middle, not a non-sequitor.)