Everyone makes certain assumptions when they critique an article. Do you read an article from a liberal without going in with a preconceived bias? No, because everyone has preconceived ideas about everything. It's perfectly normal to do so. You made certain assumptions with your posts. For example, you assumed this woman was real. You assumed her article was 100% factual. You assume she's dead now. You assumed I just didn't make this article up myself and post it.
Is it wrong that you assumed these things? No, you used evidence from the article to reinforce your assumptions. Victoria did the same. She got something different from the article than what you got. That seems to bother you a great deal.