Perhaps you are more versed in the goings on of the suit, but I think you missed the gyst of my comment. I was defending the libertarian stance on such an issue, not necessarily Jim Rob's decisions. Like I said before, I would have commercialized the sire long ago and let it stand on its own merits.
I don't buy into the Historical record stuff too much, especially considering that the archives have been down for 2 months and my posts won't even go back more then a month.