Me?
Steaks? The Post House
Fish? Manhattan Ocean Club or Le Bernardin
Chinese? Shun Lee Palace or Shun Lee West
Italian? Il Mulino
Deli? Carnegie or 2nd Ave.
American? Union Sq Cafe
French? Lutece Le Cirque
Off beat Scandi? Aquavit.
My quick scan of the Zagat selections validates most of their opinions. Pick your cuisine/price/locale.
Gotta put in a good word here for the Atlantic Grill on 3rd Ave. in the seventies, best meal I've had all year. It's a bit noisy and always crowded, but the food is great and, while not cheap, they won't be shelling out Le Bernardin-style big bucks.
I had the yellowfin tuna with a seaweed crust and the molten chocolate cake. Yum.