Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: Lent
you FRAUDULENTLY took the REFERENCE out of CONTEXT to make it APPEAR THAT COMMENT BY BEN-GURION referred to a GENERAL POLICY...MORRIS STATES CATEGORICALLY THAT THERE WAS NO POLICY TO EXPEL THE ARABS

It WAS a GENERAL POLICY. It couldn't be EXPLICITLY done because THE WHOLE COUNTRY WAS BASED ON ITS PROMISE THE ARABS COULD STAY. At a critical point in its existence, and desperatly needing external support, the country had to do expulsions sub rosa.

Further, the Isaelis couldn't very well expel all Arabs from places they did not yet control. All they could do is intimidate them, then after they took over, get rid of the rest. One village at a time.

600,000 becomes "millions". Only in your myth math world.

The 600,000 800,000 have had descendants. Their descendants are dispossessed as well. Unfortunatly for you, the 600,000 800,000 are not just going to quitely die off with no progeny.

In the meantime where is you yapping about the 800,000 Jews from Arab Islamic lands many who left because the Arab Islamics made it intollerable to live there any more?

This is your FOURTH spin on the subject. (1)First you said it didn't happen. (2)Then you said it was isolated. (3)Then you said they were a "fifth column." (4)Now you say "the Arabs did it too."

Nobody's denying Arabs did it. You're denying the Jews did.

What the Arab countries did was equally wrong, but THEY did not give assurances to the rest of the world to get worldwide support for their existence.

I said the MAJORITY left without being expelled...The 20% happened as a result of the ARAB aggressions and the war. It was an ad hoc process as the war developed in particular locations. KARSH on the other hand states there was not even any ad hoc process which developed.

The truth comes out in bits and pieces. So now Rev #6 says "Yes it did happen, it was an ad hoc process.

You're right. It was an ad hoc process. However it is an ad hoc process which continues to this day. Thank you.

182 posted on 10/05/2001 9:12:27 AM PDT by AGAviator
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 171 | View Replies ]


To: AGAviator
It WAS a GENERAL POLICY. It couldn't be EXPLICITLY done because THE WHOLE COUNTRY WAS BASED
ON ITS PROMISE THE ARABS COULD STAY. At a critical point in its existence, and desperatly needing external
support, the country had to do expulsions sub rosa.

Garbage. Don't pick and choose quotes from Morris. YOU FRAUDULENTLY USED A QUOTE FROM MORRIS AND THEN YOU HAVE NOW THROWN AWAY THE REST OF HIS COMMENTS ON THIS ISSUE. QUIT YOUR FRAUD!
 

This is your FOURTH spin on the subject. (1)First you said it didn't happen. (2)Then you said it was isolated. (3)Then you said they were a "fifth column." (4)Now you say "the Arabs did it too."

False. I said the MAJORITY left without ejection. Lie # 1 made repatedly by you now. But since you FRAUDULENTLY USE QUOTATIONS no surprise.  The other points you make follow from your lies.

Nobody's denying Arabs did it. You're denying the Jews did.

Hey Jeb. Watch close:20%. Got it.

What the Arab countries did was equally wrong, but THEY did not give assurances to the rest of the world to get worldwide support for their existence.

No one gave any assurance to Jews thrown out and NO ARAB ISLAMIC COUNTRY HAS OFFERED THEM ANYTHING for having confiscated their possessions and property.

The truth comes out in bits and pieces. So now Rev #6 says "Yes it did happen, it was an ad hoc process.

It's apparent you want to believe and say what suites you. I speak from history. You FRAUDULENTLY USE QUOTATIONS from New Historians. I'll leave the posters to determine who is lying and manipulating on this thread.

However it is an ad hoc process which continues to this day. Thank you.

Tell your Arab Islamic fascist brethren to stop the Intifada. In the meantime Israel got out of the Sinai and out of South Lebanon. What have your Pal terrorist friends done but continue their Jihad against Israel.

 

185 posted on 10/05/2001 9:30:42 AM PDT by Lent
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 182 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson