There are no alligators in Ohio. Snappers and water moccasins, ok.
I wouldn’t totally discount that. There was a story a couple of years ago about some kids on a field trip in West Middletown. That is near J.D. Vance’s hometown. There was a 7 foot crocodile seen in the creek. I have been a creek walker since a boy, wow. There was an alligator seen in the great Miami river many years ago near Trenton, Ohio.