Click here: to donate by Credit Card
Or here: to donate by PayPal
Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794
Thank you very much and God bless you.
Posted on 10/11/2025 5:49:52 PM PDT by SeekAndFind
Marc Lynch is angry. The word “rage” appears six times on the first page of America’s Middle East: The Ruination of a Region, and comes in response to Israel’s war in Gaza. This should be sufficient warning to anyone expecting a cool, calm, dispassionate analysis of the Middle East that they might have picked up the wrong book. That is not to say that Lynch, who runs the George Washington University’s Middle East program, is not worth reading. On the contrary, and despite the occasional lapse into the sort of political-science-speak favored by academics, he is a fierce and compelling voice.
Lynch dates the beginning of America’s Middle East to 1991, the conclusion of a swift military campaign against Saddam Hussein’s Iraq and the end of the bipolar era in which the US and the Soviet Union had for decades shared the responsibilities of international mediation. Contrast the hopes for the region then – Israeli-Palestinian peace, the spread of democracy and liberalizing economic reforms – with the reality of what followed: multiple wars between Israel, Hamas and Hezbollah; another war and a decade-long insurgency in Iraq; civil wars in Syria, Yemen, Libya and Sudan; and continued internal repression by regimes that can be classified as autocracies, if you are being kind, or varying shades of dictatorship if you’re feeling less charitable.
Both Israel and the United States come in for a vigorous kicking, more so than the region’s Islamists, Hamas foremost among them. This is a pity, as well as a mistake, because it undermines a wider analysis of American policy towards the Middle East that is otherwise brave, bracing and original.
It is Washington’s complicity with Arab autocracy combined with the impunity it allows Israel, irrespective of whether Republicans or Democrats are in government, which infuriates Lynch. And much of the rest of the world, too. The author is unsparing in his critique.
The US, he writes, consistently likes to present itself as “seeking to liberate the people they are immiserating”. Washington’s inability or refusal to take regional public opinion seriously has long been its “fatal flaw”. “The starting premise of American policy has always implicitly been that Palestinians are not fully human beings.”
As an avowed Obama fan who advised both presidential campaigns, he cuts the former president a lot of slack, though the title of this chapter, adapted from Obama’s memoir, gives the game away: “The Audacity, and Failure, of Hope”. Given Obama’s much vaunted hopes of changing both American policy in the region and the mindset behind it, the charge sheet against him makes depressing reading: a free pass to Gulf forces to help Bahrain’s monarchy crush its Arab Spring uprising in 2011; failure to uphold his “red line” in 2012 over Syrian president Bashar al Assad’s use of chemical weapons against his own people; the refusal to brand the 2013 Saudi- and UAE-backed rising against the democratically elected Muslim Brotherhood government in Egypt a coup.
In the words of a 2016 Brookings report, not quoted by Lynch, “when it comes to Israeli-Palestinian peacemaking, no US president has promised more and accomplished less than Obama”.
The years ahead, Lynch argues, should cause concern for Israelis. The younger generation of Americans, who do not have political memories extending to Israel’s foundation in 1948, are considerably more pro-Palestinian than their parents. When the US finds itself alone, again and again, wielding its Security Council veto in defense of Israel, that demographic shift should ring alarm bells in Jerusalem and Washington. Likewise, as Lynch observes, for decades the bipartisan consensus in the US on Israel barely needed to be openly defended. Today it is under active discussion at every level.
There is a reason that Benjamin Netanyahu refuses to discuss “the day after” the war in Gaza has ended. We know that it does not involve the beginning of talks with the Palestinians leading to a two-state solution, because he has ruled out a Palestinian state. In many minds, the obvious alternative, a single state, will be tantamount to apartheid. Lynch notes that the quartet composed of Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, the Israeli human rights organization B’Tselem and the International Court of Justice considers “the international legal criteria for the crime of apartheid” to have been met already.
On 16 September, a UN report accused Israel of committing genocide, adding to the country’s deepening international isolation days ahead of the planned recognition by a handful of countries, including the UK, France, Canada and Australia, of the state of Palestine at the UN’s General Assembly.
What comes after Gaza? Like many experts, Lynch has already written off the two-state solution and reckons “an unsustainable apartheid may be a surer route towards the attainment of Palestinian rights than the perpetual pretense of the fantasy of two states”. To quote the title of the Egyptian-American writer Omar El Akkad’s excoriating book on the West’s complicity in the horrors of Gaza, One Day Everyone Will Have Always Been Against This.
|
|
Click here: to donate by Credit Card Or here: to donate by PayPal Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794 Thank you very much and God bless you. |
What should we expect from the United States of Sodom? No one reads God’s Word and understands His prophecies regarding the regathering of the Jews in the last days for salvation. I wouldn’t doubt they convert to Islam and join the Jihad against Christianity and Israel
I am against Islamic terrorism the same way I am against the doctrinal terrorism and damage wrought by the Left Behind / Late Great Planet / Rapture Ready IDOLATRY.
The TRUTH is, there are Bible-believing Christians rediscovering historical Eschatology and prophetic frameworks held to by the church BEFORE the 19th Century — thereby ushering in a generation of Christian teachers, leaders, and ministers who will have a healthier understanding of Israel, both in the physical and spiritual.
In the end it’s all about JESUS! And salvation is for Jews and Gentiles Amen!
The views of today’s young Americans makes me question if America has America’s backing. They seem to be a bunch of brainwashed leftist lemmings these days.
No. Between young Americans and crippling public and private debt there will be no affirming concern for Israel. America likely just a token participant in the Magog coalition. Redemption is for indiduals, not nations (except Israel?).
Um…ok. The Antenicene church fathers believed in a millennial reign of Christ, a regathering of the Jewish people in Israel in the last days, and a Harpazo of the Church. What specific idolatry are you referring to? BTW…Left Behind was fiction. Did you not know that?
Unfortunately, for many it WAS the Book of Revelation. That's my point! SO problematic. We're in a detox era.
If your theology or your political analysis have led you on-side with Hamas and Fatah you’ve made a wrong turn somewhere.
Israel did not have US’ backing under odoofus the illegal islamic and creepy gropin’ pedophile slowjoe’s admins. I seriously doubt the clintoonian admin supported Israel considering the pressure put on Israel to agree to araRATfink’s demands which he did. Then araRATfink turned down the agreement when the palis would have gotten every thing they wanted. Plus, ol’ murderess of benghazi referred to one person as “that f*****g Jew.”
Aw the good old days when the Jews were said to run everything including the press, politics, and colleges. How did such powerful devious Jews lose all that power to the poor oppressed Palestinians and Muslims invading every aspect of western society and openly DLL for the total annihilation of Jews? Did the media and democrats lie to us again?
Oh look
Another opportunity taken by the boards leading foot soldier of FRantifa
To attack and sow religious division and discord.
Your moma must be so proud.
Zechariah 12:3-4
“On that day, when all the nations of the earth are gathered against her, I will make Jerusalem an immovable rock for all the nations. All who try to move it will injure themselves.”
On that day, says the Lord, I will smite every horse with bewilderment, and its rider with madness. And upon the house of Judah I will open My eyes, and all the horses of the peoples I will smite with blindness.”
Zechariah 14:2
“And I will gather all the nations to Jerusalem to wage war; and the city shall be captured, and the houses shall be plundered, and the women shall be ravished, and half the city shall go forth into exile-and the rest of the people shall not be cut off from the city.”
Thankfully the tides are shifting outside the toxic chambers of FR.
In real life, even dispensationalists pray for the peace of Jerusalem and spend more time praying for salvation of individuals and for the triumph of the Gospel in Israel than anything else.
Israel needs to be able to survive without the USA, because the USA will be going away. Not right away, but still.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.