Looking at that photo of the house, I’m waiting for Mayhem to say, “If you don’t have Allstate, you could be paying for this yourself.”
Allstate will tell you that they’re not responsible to pay for the damage to the house. They will tell you to sue the police for the damage & good luck with that.
https://ij.org/if-you-break-it-you-buy-it-unless-youre-the-police/