American Samoans are US nationals not natural born citizens. There have been court cases in recent years about this, even pending legislation, but nothing has been done to change the status of people born in American Samoa.
Ok, I will grant the American Samoa thing, but the fact remains that both her parents were US citizens. She is in the same boat as John McCain (born of US citizens in the Panama Canal Zone).
The objection to Obama was based on the argument that his American mother could not confer US citizenship because of anti female laws at the time (1961). Which is a crock, because children of American mothers and foreign fathers have always gotten US passports automatically. My uncle for one, and hes got more than 20 years on Obama. But I digress.
With both parents?