[SauronOfMordor]

We can have 18 year old privates as long as they have 25 year old sergeants providing mature judgement, something teens lack.

How is Ukraine’s experienced NCO corps holding up?

[Zhang Fei]

Ukraine ping

Sauron: [We can have 18 year old privates as long as they have 25 year old sergeants providing mature judgement, something teens lack.

How is Ukraine’s experienced NCO corps holding up?]

---

With these things, the proof of the pudding is in the eating. In a recent article, at one point in the line, what the Ukrainians call a brigade, basically a reinforced battalion of 2,000 men, was holding back a Russian division 6 to 12 times its size, despite Russia’s 10 to 1 howitzer shell advantage. That the Ukrainian line did not pull back a dozen miles is testament to a blend of something that’s preventing superior Russian numbers, firepower and close air support from gaining more than incremental ground. Whether grit, creativity or sheer luck, it held in the face of ammo starvation.

Whatever the reason, it suggests that man for man, the Ukrainian soldier is more than a match for several of his Russian counterparts. The problem is Biden’s deliberate starvation of Ukrainian equipment and ammo flows. Until he stops the micromanagement, Ukraine’s road will not be an easy one. The US gave Russia as much as 6% of 1941’s economic output (also 6x the 1% pre-WW2 US military budget). It is giving Ukraine 0.2% of 2024’s economic output, or 1/30 what it gave Russia in WW2. That difference, combined with Biden’s deliberate dispatch of mostly junkyard grade equipment and light over heavy weaponry, is why the Ukrainian recovery of its prewar territory isn’t a sure thing.