I think he’s much younger there. IN Wikipedia’s article, there’s a much younger pic (maybe passport?) that looks rather human. The years/miles have been hard on him.
For example, the name Dmitry Utkin has apparently been recycled several times to disguise the business interests and connections of the Wagners/Prigozhin, including once using a Russian prison convict who changed his name legally to Dmitry Utkin.
This stuff comes from western intelligence sources, not Russian ones. For instance the linked article was focused on 'proving' Wagner's ties to the Kremlin but contains a plethora of other information/links to sift thru.
Putin Chef's Kisses of Death: Russia's Shadow Army's State-Run Structure Exposed