[NautiNurse]

There are 6 conservatives. Why was it 5-4?

Because the decision was 6-3. Roberts went with the majority vote, but he wrote his own opinion, rather than signing on to Alito's opinion.

[montag813]

Because the decision was 6-3. Roberts went with the majority vote, but he wrote his own opinion, rather than signing on to Alito's opinion.

Wow. That is pathetic. And the idiot Bush had to make this wussy "Chief Justice" right from the start. HE should have wrote the opinion and put his stamp on it.