I think that Cherries and Cream that had spoiled were blamed for the death of William Henry Harrison, the shortest serving president at 1 month.
Cherries & cream? Cherries and (Ice) Cream are close.
Is it possible that history could repeat?
I believe you are referring the the speculation about the death of Zachary Taylor, seemingly debunked by a modern autopsy. Harrison died several weeks after giving a Fidel Castro-length inaugural address in near freezing rain sans overcoat.