Posted on 02/17/2020 12:24:59 PM PST by Borges
I'll bet he knew the Nashville Number System.
I liked both, for different reasons. Either one would suit me to watch on a rainy winter afternoon.
>>Hate to say it and nothing against John Wayne, but the 2010 movie version was much better.<<
There was a time I would have shot you for saying that. I refused to watch the remake for a long time. But I finally watched it and it is pretty damn good, it sort of grew on me.
>>We have no rodeo clowns in Yell County.<<
Lawyer J Nobel Dagget will be in contact soon.
Wonderful writer. I’ve always planned to do a True Grit tour (the book, not the film) starting in Fort Smith. This just gives me impetus! RIP, Charles Portis.
Which, in my mind, was a problem.
I just couldn't get over the the stilted, formal dialog, although I'm sure the Coens reveled in it. I can understand that in a stylized work like "O Brother, Where Art Thou?", but this is a Western, and I couldn't get into the story. Every time a character spoke, the story came to a screeching halt because there the author was, sticking his nose in.
You should enjoy this...from 1969...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kIYvHdEwEOw
One of the original music vids???
True Grit was a very good novel, and John Waynes realization of Cogburn is legendary; rightfully so. I thought Darby was pretty darn good, as well. I stayed away from watching the remake for years how could they attempt such blasphemy? However, I finally gave in and really enjoyed it. Bridges was excellent.
Real music.
Charles Portis was a sergeant in he Marine Corps.
I also preferred the Bridges/Steinfeld remake.
It was intrusive, but in a good, "this is out of the ordinary" way. And I thought it gave the characters ... character.
May Mr. Portis REST IN PEACE.
Yours, TMN78247
Wayne was doing self parody in “True Grit”. He should have won an Oscar for one of his great films with John Ford or Howard Hawks.
The score was what made the 2010 version superior for me.
Who all here grew up eating sofkee?
Not me. Or Burgoo - 2 meals mentioned in that wonderfully atmospheric novel.
I see the usual STEM types are showing up here with their unutterably dumb film reviews. It never fails here.
To have one character speak in such a manner creates an interesting character. When all the characters speak that way, it strips the dialog of authenticity; the characters no longer seem real, but more like actors in a play.
Again, I thought it worked in "O Brother, Where Art Thou?"
If you are referring to me, I thought both were excellent films.
All the actors except Campbell were outstanding. The directing and cinematography were superb. And the Coen version portrayed a beautiful, gritty(!) realism superior to the original.
I wish I could get over the dialog.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.