Sorry, he is. You are either a citizen by birth or by naturalization. voicereason was a citizen born. Every court agrees with me.
I strongly oppose birthright citizenship to people here illegally. But the situation voicereason describes is NBC. Vattel did not discuss NBC.
Citizen at birth was rejected by the founders as insufficient.
They chose the strictest standard, natural born citizen.
One is only NATURALLY a citizen if one CANNOT possibly be anything else.
Anyone born with more than ONE nationality is NOT NATURALLY a citizen.
http://www.art2superpac.com/issues.html