Like most other 9th circuit decisions this will be overturned, especially now with Ginsburg out.
I don’t know how many of you have elderly parents but they don’t recover from bone breaks well. Rib fractures usually cause pnemonia as well. It did with Rand Paul and he ain’t elderly. I lost both my MiL and my father to pnemonia.
I don’t think Ginsburg is out. Do you have a citation?