Ah, see now that he counter’s her claim. Still, he wasn’t there.
It would be considered legal testimony to her character in court, while you point out the obvious, of course he wasn’t there, anything beyond that would be considered hearsay.
The age of consent in 34 states more or less is 16 year old and Alabama is one of them. So nothing illegal or untowardly about a 32 year old man hitting on 16 year olds.
Go find out about how young the Amish or Mormon women get married at still to this day with men older than 32.
Likewise, you weren't there either. What is your point about truth and lies?
He did not need to be there to know the truth. Are you incapable of determining the truth of a matter based on available facts?