Posted on 11/04/2017 4:11:18 AM PDT by Kaslin
A travesty of justice occurred on Friday. A deserter with blood on his heels will walk free, leaving dead and maimed Americans in his wake, because of a bully’s pulpit and a weak man’s bench and gavel. The miscarriage results from a president who tweets too much and a judge who discerns too little.
Candidate Trump tweeted some harsh things about the consequences he believed deserter Bowe Bergdahl should face. Among other things, Trump called Bergdahl a “dirty rotten traitor” and a “no good traitor who should have been executed.”
Commentators expressed concern at the time about inappropriate command influence prejudicing military proceedings. Military commanders are not supposed to twist subordinate arms about military justice, not even the Commander in Chief. But, candidates are not commanders. Yet.
Still, based on Trump’s angry blasts, Bergdahl’s lawyers sought a pardon or commuta tion from President Obama. They also sought a dismissal or other leniency from authorities presiding over the court martial. They were turned away in both instances. The presiding judge announced that he had not been influenced by Trump’s public outbursts. In any event, Trump had no command authority when he tweeted. The case continued.
After Bergdahl pled guilty, however, reporters challenged Trump about his pre-election tweets, asking if he had fatally tainted the prosecution. As National Review’s Legal Analyst and former federal prosecutor Andrew McCarthy points out, the only reasonable response for the seated Commander in Chief to offer is “No comment.” Trump needlessly volunteered to the effect: “People heard what I said.”
Commentators again tutted that Trump was renewing his previous efforts at interference by publicly endorsing his prior thinking. But this time, he did it as president and Commander in Chief. Therefore, he put unlawful pressure on the military and its court martial system. The New York Times reported that the JAG Corps judge was willing to take the bait:
“I will consider the president’s comments as mitigation evidence as I arrive at an appropriate sentence,” the judge, Col. Jeffery R. Nance of the Army, said during a hearing at Fort Bragg.'”
Today Col. Nance sentenced Bergdahl to a minor fine and a dishonorable discharge. The ruling allows the man who wrote anti-American screeds, who left his post and cost valiant Americans’ their lives and health to walk free on America’s streets. No word yet on his possible book and movie deals.
Nance’s statement is an illogical disgrace and Bergdahl’s sentence is a travesty.
Nothing in law or logic makes the president's intemperate outbursts or his subsequent mention of them “mitigation” for the crimes of Bergdahl. They are eternal noise that should have no bearing on the proceeding or Nance’s judgment. They provide no information to suggest Berdahl’s betrayal is less treacherous to his nation or less dangerous for his comrades. They do not shed light on Bergdahl’s mental or physical health, or provide any basis to excuse his actions.
The president’s ill-advised words don’t mitigate in favor of Berdahl. They weigh against continuing the case. The run the risk of tainting the prosecution by undue influence. The case then, should either be deemed compromised and dismissed, or the statements excluded and ignored, and justice administered by the book. They provide no factual, legal, or moral justification to alter a just sentence in the Bergdahl’s favor.
This is especially true in a case where the relevant decision maker is a judge and not a jury. Federal rules of evidence allow the exclusion of evidence that may be more prejudicial than relevant or probative. But the concern is primarily about improperly influencing lay jurors. Col. Nance is not an impressionable member of a jury who needs to be protected from sensational headlines. He is a sworn and trained officer and jurist. His appropriate comment should have been: "I will disregard the president's irrelevant and inadmissible commentary. "
He should not have said, and then acted, on the suggestion that he would actually use the president’s comments as a thumb on the scale to benefit the defendant.
Nance might have meant his ruling as a defiant middle finger aimed at President Trump (which, itself would indicate he was not influenced by unlawful pressure). But, the ruling did not produce a gesture at the president. It was much bigger. It fully, offensively spoke to the men and women who serve and sacrifice, their families, and millions of informed Americans who bear witness.
May God please comfort the families and rest the souls of the men who died searching to find and rescue the deserter. And may Karma please visit Barack Obama and Susan Rice in their thoughts and dreams and torment them for the lies they knowingly told the nation about former Private Bergdahl.
This military officer judge is a complete stoolie
No confidence any more in ANY federal gub mint anything.
We all know the fbi, irs, cia is now horse shit.
Guess much of our military has become such also.
If this judge is not relieved of duty, I will say publicly that I am ashamed of the Army I served so long.
Officers cant be busted to private without their own court martial but he can be “dismissed from the Army” which for an officer is the same thing as a Dishonorable dischrage. He can also be relieved of his duties as a judge by his superiors including the Secretary of the Army, Sec of Defense and even the President. All officers serve at the pleasure of the President so he could be retired at the end of the month when all Army retirements for that month take place. That is exactly what should happen.
The Dems will be happy. Another contender that the neo-commies can get behind in the next presidential election.
He will be the new cause celebre and will be running for some kind of local office by at least 2020. He will land on his feet like the morally decrepit always do.
“So it’s Trump’s fault according to this idiot.”
It will always be Trump’s fault for as long as it flies with the communist wannabes in the general population.
(Works like a charm with the hammer and sickle waving scu&bags in the electorate.)
IMHO
He will be dead within a year.
Judge Nance is a blemish on Military justice and his sentence is as insulting to most Americans as is the NFL. My guess, Bergdahl will be looking over his shoulder for quite some time.
“This will be a self correcting problem at the end of the trail.”
I spent most of my life connected to the military, and this is only the beginning of the issue. Bergdahl may have walked, but others won’t. Justice is flexible. It isn’t always handed out by courts, or policemen, or politicians, or anyone in particular. If the member is going to walk while violating the basic rule in the business of watching your neighbor’s six, he/she won’t reach those levels. They just might be killed in action. And I’m not advocating this, but it has happened before.
rwood
Of course they have oversight. The judiciary has its own chain of supervision/command.
Colonel, USAFR (RET)
Any History or background info on this Judge Nance?
So it’s Trump’s fault according to this idiot.
Virtue signalling Never Trumpers show once again they hate Trump more than they love their country. Did you EVER in 8 YEARS hear A SINGLE Democrat complain the kenyan was exerting undue command influence? No. Now POTUS makes a basic statement of fact comment that 1% warmer than “no comment” and the usual suspect Never Trumpers jump down his throat.
Bergdahl and these surrender monkey Never Trump “conservatives” show us the leftist march through our institutions is complete, IMO. We may win a few battles with Trump but America has lost the war. RIP.
If this judge is not relieved of duty, I will say publicly that I am ashamed of the Army I served so long.
Relieved? Twinkle Toes Mattis will decorate him. PC and progressive commissars have totally corrupted the military, IMO.
The judge sees a chance to give Trump the finger and can't resist...justice be damned.
It’s become a routine for all libturd judges to base their decisions on politics and whatever can bring more money and power to corrupt lawyers. They run every branch of federal and state governments, they now run healthcare, and they get a piece of every business.
You are right, the highly advertised Mattis has not lifted a finger to clean out the rot in the military. In fact he all but countermanded Trump’s order to get rid of cross dressers. A huge disappointment. Everything that is wrong with the military today is vested in Mattis now.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.