You could say that but they were still way off. If you put half the Gulf of Mexico within the cone, you’re probably going to be right.
The point is, they always say, be prepared if you are in the cone. Also, forecasting has improved since Katrina so the cones are smaller, but there is always a fair amount of uncertainty more than 3 days out.
Add to that: None of the major models show anything like that. The Euro and the UKMet especially have been on target all along.
So is there a 0% chance that Irma does something weird? No, but those odds are probably no more than 1-2%.
So y'all stop cherry-picking rogue storms to confuse people.