[csivils]

I read it the exact opposite way... that the ruling wouldn’t have been required if there was a national reciprocity bill. The heart of the issue (for one of the cases) was that one sheriff had a much tougher interpretation of good cause. That would be a moot point if the same Sheriff had to honor permits from other states.

[Sooth2222]

"Does not bode well for a national reciprocity bill if the Court is not willing to overturn, or even review, lower court decisions that keep control at the state level."

"I read it the exact opposite way... that the ruling wouldn’t have been required if there was a national reciprocity bill. The heart of the issue (for one of the cases) was that one sheriff had a much tougher interpretation of good cause. That would be a moot point if the same Sheriff had to honor permits from other states."

I don't think we want a SC precedent until there are 5 firm 2A votes. Kennedy may be getting squishy in his old age. Better to wait until Kennedy AND Ginsburg retire.