Illinois is directly adjacent to Indiana and will most certainly vote Dem.
Pence adds nothing to the ticket as far as votes go. Nothing.
If VP could bring along his state, every VP candidate would be from Florida.
The enthusiasm for Palin still left McCain a million votes short of what Romney/Ryan would get four years later.
Pence may not add much, but he also doesn’t subtract much.
And Pence is believed to have no recognition at all among Buckeyes.