Posted on 04/25/2016 3:44:56 PM PDT by SMGFan
federal appeals court has ruled a New Jersey couple can't sue to keep a stolen 7.35-carat diamond, even though it was given as a gift from mother to daughter, the couple's attorney confirmed on Monday. The pear-shaped diamond was stolen in 2003 and made its way through various sellers before ending up purchased for $175,000 by Saddle River resident Frank Walsh, according to previous reports.
In 2012, Walsh's wife gave the diamond as a gift to their daughter, Suzanne, and son-in-law Steven Zaretsky.
When the Zaretskys tried to have the diamond insured, a jeweler discovered the gem had been stolen in 2003 by celebrity stylist Derek Khan, according to reports.
(Excerpt) Read more at nj.com ...
Perhaps it's possible to recover some money from them?
I use to sell jewelry. You never buy diamonds retail as an investment piece. They are like cars. As soon as you leave the store the price starts ticking downwards.
Must have been Tony Soprano’s crew...
Well, the buyers will have to sue the seller for the money they paid for the stolen gem
The buyer loses the gem to the police, the police turn it over to the rightful owner
It is the buyer’s responsibility to sue the seller
And that seller can sue his supplier, etc
That is how it works
The victim, the original owner who had the diamond stolen from, should be made in whole. Everyone else, even though some might be innocent, have to take it to the courts to get their money back.
Bookmark
Okay...
Outta my league!
Last diamond I priced was in the 1/4 to 1/3 carat range.
I agree that the original owner should get his property back, but if he received an insurance settlement for his loss, he should give that money back.
Me neither.
But one of the most reliable scams is to make the mark think that he or she is getting a killer deal, “a steal,” so that greed clouds their sense of logic.
The rule when purchasing something: be willing to walk away from the deal even and especially if the sales person threatens to rescind his offer if you leave.
Also, I wonder if they had it inspected and appraised.
Ya. Me too.
I can think of better things to spend $175K on... if I had it.
Diamonds are one of the most common gemstones on the planet... The scam around diamond value is comical when you think about it.. and now they are even trying to convince folks that diamonds that are of crap quality and clarity are valuable as well by labeling them “chocolate” and putting a high price tag on them.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.