There are many SCOTUS decision where 9 of 9 justices necessarily operate from the premise that a person born abroad is an alien, unless naturalized by Congress. You are probably unable to understand that, and so you will reword your criteria for finding that rule of law to be settled.
“There are many SCOTUS decision where 9 of 9 justices necessarily operate from the premise that a person born abroad is an alien, unless naturalized by Congress”
I’m not ok with calling a 5-4 decision a correct decision. It may be a decision, but if it was passed on partisan or ideological grounds, then that decision is political and no worthy of respect. Either something is constitutional or it is not. I know, I’m in the minority. I don’t always buy what people spew as settled law. Sorry.