[randita]

Not to be flippant, but e.g. God reveals one meaning of “natural born” to you and a different meaning of “natural born” to me. Who determines which meaning is the correct one?

Who gets to divide the baby?

[Godebert]

Not to be flippant, but e.g. God reveals one meaning of “natural born” to you and a different meaning of “natural born” to me. Who determines which meaning is the correct one? Who gets to divide the baby?

The meaning as understood by the Founding Fathers is the one that matters. That definition was found in The Law of Nations or the Principles of Natural Law (1758)

[Cboldt]

You aks a good question there. Politics is like war. The winner is usually whoever has the bigger army. It really is that simple.

As long as there is a plausible way to spin the facts into the conclusion you want, you won't lose supporters. There is no "right" other than "might."