Except the other side is MUCH more afraid of Christians than of muslims.
By making explicit policy based on religion, you make it that much easier for them to come after other religions.
That is why this isn’t well thought out. It would create a precedent that will be used against us.
“By making explicit policy based on religion, . . .”
But Islam isn’t a religion, being a war plan and a death cult.
Only if you let them. We didn't have a problem making Mormons disavow polygamy. Sharia would be no different.