NYer: “Which popes met the supposed criteria of Pope Pius XII and how was this criteria established. sic”
There you go, sounding just like a protestant, questioning a pope! Who are you to question Pope Pius XII’s criteria? Or in your own words, “Do we each become our own judge of what is part of the teaching magisterium of the Church?”
NYer: “You asked: What is your criteria for belief and trust in Vicars of Christ on earth?
Again you haven’t answered me your position but rather found fault with mine. Again, I will answer you when you have classified yourself with regard to the question that I already answered: What criteria do you use for which popes were valid and which were not?
Apparently you did not read my response, posted above.