It’s akin to saying, “I don’t like Trump” and the response is, “You love Obama.”
And then someone says, "I don't like Obama" and the response ISN'T, "You love Trump."
Holding to different standards. Yes, we see the "X, therefore P" as a non-sequitur and likewise "not X, therefore not P" (X and P having absolutely nothing to do with each other), that someone DOES hold a different axiom seeing a connection between X and P belies inconsistency (in the form of bigotry in this case) when they fail to acknowledge a connection (in THEIR axiom set, not ours) between !X and !P.
Jesuits? Ha ha.