Replies

Author afraid to take ownership????
SNOPES: The ONLY real question to be tackled regarding this humorous parable supposedly explaining “how taxes really work” is its authorship, and the investigation reveals this item to be one of those favored pieces of writing adopted and reprinted by numerous columnists without their knowing (or necessarily caring) who originally penned it.

The signature block at the bottom of the currently circulating Internet version identifies it as being the work of “T. Davies,” a Professor of Accounting at the University of South Dakota.

Professor Thomas Davies does indeed teach at USD’s School of Business, but when we inquired of him whether he was the originator of this piece, we received the following response:

Thank you for your message. I previously distributed the “How Taxes Really Work” article (as well as other opinion pieces reflecting different perspectives) to my graduate tax class to encourage them to think beyond the rules and regulations. Unfortunately, it is rather easy to focus on the myriad of complex rules and forget that tax policy frequently influences taxpayer behavior beyond what may have been intended. Thus my students are frequently asked to think “outside the box,” and consider such topics a tax complexity, alternative forms of taxation, and the impact of taxes on behavior. The article was not written by me, and I have intentionally avoided commenting on its validity in order to encourage my students to think critically, and to assist in the development of their analytical and communication skills. I am unaware of the true author’s identity, which is unfortunate, since the piece has generated considerable interest. Unfortunately, one of my students sent it along and erroneously contributed the authorship to me.

Leave it to snopes.com to figure out a way to keep from labeling this “True”. But, of course, we know they’re objective truth-seekers, right?

I heard it or a version real similar years ago but never knew or do not remember where it came from.

But it is right on the button.

seriously? you quote SNOPES?

The ones who claim Obama’s birth certificate is REAL?

If your going to make up stuff a professor said, everybody knows you’re supposed to use Joel Olson.