Good decision.
Thomas and Alito probably would have wished to make some sort of reasonability test for how long, the problem with that is the STATE seems to take a BROAD view on what is reasonable for it and a NARROW view of responsibility for citizens.
My view and I think the founders is that as broad a view on the rights of the citizen and as narrow a view on the powers of the state SHOULD be the standard.
I have heard it said that citizens have rights.
The government doesn’t have rights, it has responsibilities