Posted on 03/27/2015 9:03:58 AM PDT by Star Traveler
Here is Marcia Freedman, in a J-Street panel discussion on Liberal Zionism and sitting next to Peter Beinart, describing how she believes that the Jewish people should not have a state, and that instead they should live as a minority in an Arab Palestine as a “protected minority” – in other words, as dhimmis. I kept all the context (although I accidentally cut out the applause at the end:)
Isn’t it interesting that at a conference that claims to be “pro-Israel, pro-peace” and that hammers away at how it wants a two state solution, there is no objection to this one-state solution where Jews are “protected” by people who want to kill them?
J-Street refuses to let Alan Dershowitz, an advocate of a two-state solution since the 1970s, speak. But this crazy lady who thinks that Israel treats Arab citizens worse than Arabs would treat Jews is given a platform, without a single dissenting voice that I could find, either at the session or on Twitter afterwards, from J-Street members or attendees.
(Excerpt) Read more at algemeiner.com ...
Of course they have to keep silent about it, if they want to keep their head.
And it seems that pretty much all of them have chosen to live right where they are, except for a very few privileged and rich ones who roam the world ... :-) ...
But in term of talking about Jews or Israel ... well ... I don’t have to be gay to talk about gays, I don’t have to be liberal to talk about liberals, I don’t have to support abortion to talk about abortion, I don’t have to be a drug addict to talk about drug addicts, and so on with each and every group you can come up with in the world.
And absolutely no one in ANY of those groups can ever cause anyone to stop talking and discussing them ... even when they might say, “Well, you’re not one of us, so what you say means nothing since you don’t understand!”
If ANYONE HERE believed that, we would have stopped talking and discussing ... many years ago!
I’ve heard that kind of ridiculous argument before and it normally causes me to laugh my head off ... LOL ...
As far as being Jewish ... I fully support the JEWISH Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, in his support for the TWO-STATE SOLUTION, per his Bar-Ilan speech and back him in his support for equal rights for all in Israel, regardless of race, religion or gender.
I think the JEWISH Prime Minister is doing everything right, as he should be!
If you’d like to be on or off, please FR mail me.
..................
They'll be protected like they were in the Arab world, like Christians are now.
The Final Solution is fine with hussein.
Take a look at what I just posted here ...
Column One: Managing Obama’s war against Israel
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/3272989/posts
Agree it’s something we don’t know about?.
They must be hanging out together in the garage because I've never encountered any other than A+Bert.......
The Arabs would not permit the Jews to live if they had power over them. This pervert is a liar.
There are actually quite a few of those kinds of FREEPERS who want that, and I think they want it out of TOTAL IGNORANCE that it means the DESTRUCTION of Israel. They actually think they are doing Israel a favor by DEMANDING IT for Israel.
It goes by several names and some of these FREEPERS don’t even know that. One name is a “Bi-National State” (although I don’t see Freepers using this name). Another name is the “One-State Solution” (and normally that name is not used either).
What you’ll see most FREEPERS using is something to the effect, “Well, Israel won it during the war and it’s theirs!” Or, some will say, “God says all of Israel belongs to them!” And so, the Freepers’ statements all refer to Israel taking over (i.e., annexing it) all the land they won during the 1967 war!
These FREEPERS apparently don’t know that means a ONE-STATE SOLUTION, the very thing that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says he WILL NOT DO (because that means Israel will have about SIX MILLION ARABS added to Israel!).
Netanyahu will NEVER ALLOW THAT ... as Israel ALREADY has 20% of the population of Israel as ARABS, and in the last election, the ARABS became the THIRD LARGEST PARTY in Israel! Adding SIX MILLION MORE ARABS would destroy Israel as “the Homeland for the Jews”!!
SO, LET ME ASK YOU ... How many FREEPERS have you heard saying that Israel should take over “all the land” because it BELONGS to them! ??
Those are the FREEPERS who are DEMANDING THE DESTRUCTION OF ISRAEL!!
You’re right ... and I want you to remember how right you are, when you hear some people — who say that they are “friends of Israel” — telling other people that “Israel should take over all the land because it belongs to them anyway!”
Those people are IGNORANTLY putting Israel in a position where ARABS will rule over them (by Israel taking over all the land). Some of them, however are not saying it ignorantly and they think the Arabs should rule over the Jews!
No, you don't ask me anything until you answer my question! Just who are the FReepers who are demanding an end to Israel and calling for a one nation state????????
The ones whom I just described ...
And if you’re asking for specific names, I can give you one just recently who wants Israel to “end the occupation” and says the world should quit letting Israel get away with their oppression and put sanctions on them and quit all military aid.
I can give you that name only because it happened in the last couple of days and I still remember the name, otherwise I don’t bother “tracking Freepers” for their different viewpoints ... :-) ...
Let me know if you want the name, otherwise you can spot them on your own from the description given.
Go for it bro, who is he? And why all the secrecy?
And when you do provide me the name, extend them the courtesy by pinging them and bringing them into the conversation........I'm sure they would appreciate the opportunity in defending themselves against your not only idiotic but baseless accusation...........
You’ve got the info in a note to you, and since you have the thread, you’ll be able to engage him ... I’m finished engaging him on the subject.
I don’t intend to bring him in on the conversation, but since you’ll have the thread and the comments that I’m giving you, you’ll be able to engage him yourself ...
Nobody here is going to play your silly game, either Ping whoever it is to this thread or shut up...............
You've been throwing out accusations against fellow FReepers this entire thread so either put up or shut up..........
I think most of them mean that when the Arabs attacked Israel, Israel should have pushed the Arabs out of the area and taken it over permanently; same goes if attacked again; I doubt the folks saying that think Israel should annex it “arabs and all,” but are assuming that when the Israelis have to go in to stop the shelling periodically that the arabs flee ahead of them and could thus be “locked out.”
Their view is that the Israelis are “too nice” to go Andy Jackson on the Palestinians.
I’m not engaging a confirmed Israel hater, again. If you want to, you know where he is. And you can clearly see from reading his comments, if you don’t want to engage him yourself.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.