Neither good for a car in my humble opinion.
I was looking at one of those for my Jeep, since the console model isn’t available for the 2002 Grand Cherokee Laredo.
I had to take Dad to York Cty Courthouse last week, to get his stolen CCW replaced, and was required to leave Kimber 1911 .45, 2 extra mag holster and cellphone in vehicle, parked on street. I buried it under back seat, black floormat, but I didn’t like that insecurity for even 20mins.
Should be okay as long as it’s bolted-down good.