[TangledUpInBlue]

Thanks, I’ll check this out. All I’m saying is that I believe we CONTRIBUTE. How much? Don’t know. But I get what you’re saying.

I own my own wine business/website. (Media) The last time I was in Tuscany, I was walking vineyards that were 700 meters in elevation. The vineyard was strewn with clam and oyster shells. No greater evidence of past climate change could there have been IMO.

[bestintxas]

“The vineyard was strewn with clam and oyster shells. No greater evidence of past climate change could there have been IMO.”

I suggest you obtain some good reading from a geology book that explains how the earth has changed over the millennia.

The world is in a state of flux always, and will always be that way.

If man, who cannot even control a single thunderstorm, believes it can change the entire world, then it is delusional. It would be like changing the salinity of the oceans by throwing in a few teaspoonful’s of salt.

[july4thfreedomfoundation]

“The vineyard was strewn with clam and oyster shells.”
_____________________________________________________

They could have been deposited there by a long-ago tsunami caused by a massive undersea earthquake or volcanic event in pre-historic times.

[Spartan79]

The last time I was in Tuscany, I was walking vineyards that were 700 meters in elevation. The vineyard was strewn with clam and oyster shells. No greater evidence of past climate change could there have been IMO.

I wonder: could clam and oyster shells have been spread on the vineyard as an amendment to adjust soil ph?

[SVTCobra03]

The earth quit warming in 1998. Any climate change has to do with solar activity and nothing to do with humans.