This is genuinely unrealistic of that church. I think they have attempted to find a common ground with Islam in “morality” but the problem is you can’t stop with “morality.” “Morality” can serve the devil too and it’s one of the wickedest and cruelest things the devil can do.
The character of the God you affirm matters.
It most certainly does. It's not difficult to tell when one is not serving the God of scripture.