Posted on 12/01/2014 10:41:49 PM PST by 2ndDivisionVet
In the past few years, political-science professor Jeremy Walling and former colleague Will Miller have delved into the tea party's influence on politics and policies, and some of what they found surprised them.
Walling and Miller -- a former political-science professor at Southeast Missouri State University, now director of Institutional Research at Flagler College in St. Augustine, Florida -- edited "Tea Party Effects on 2010 U.S. Senate Elections: Stuck in the Middle to Lose" and "The Political Battle Over Redistricting."
November's midterm elections were a victory party for the Republicans and the tea party. But, while Miller said the tea party has had a "great influence" on policy, it's not the way everyone assumes.
" ... We haven't seen an influx of national policy decisions that scream 'tea party.' We haven't abolished the IRS or stopped any military actions, but there [have] been underlying influences," Miller said.
"The Republican 'tsunami' comes down to nothing but the expected backlash against a second-term president at the midpoint."
"What really is more impressive for the GOP was gubernatorial victories in places like Massachusetts and Illinois, plus holding on in Wisconsin and Florida while dominating in Ohio. Heck, Cleveland and Youngstown, Ohio, both voted for a Republican governor for the first time in decades," Miller wrote.
Underlying that, however, is passage of initiatives and referendums, such as legalizing personal use of marijuana that passed in Washington, D.C., and Oregon. In Florida, more than 50 percent of voters backed medical marijuana, but the initiative failed because they needed 60 percent, Miller said.
"[People] seem to be showing fatigue of Obama, which isn't surprising," Miller said. "He decided, on his own, to spend his first term fixing health care when the country was clamoring for attention to go on the economy. Now with ISIS, a lot of Americans want to see strength in foreign policy, and that has never been an Obama strength."
In their research, Walling said one of the things that surprised him and Miller was the portrayal of tea party members as "boneheads" or "uneducated."
"What we found was that they were educated ... a lot of them wealthy. They were people who had disposable time and disposable income to go to a rally in the middle of the day and protest what was going on in government. ... I don't know that we were necessarily surprised to see that, but it was because we were kind of suspicious of the narrative that these were just dumb morons showing up to these rallies. Actually, it turns out they were more educated than the average citizen, they were wealthier than the average citizen; their backgrounds were different from what ... people thought," Walling said.
The other thing Walling and Miller concluded was something they already knew: A strong candidate is a strong candidate, and a weak candidate is a weak candidate. He gave the example of former Nevada Assembly member Sharron Angle, who ran against U.S. Sen. Harry Reid, a Democrat.
"You take somebody like Sharron Angle in Nevada. Sharron Angle was all the rage on talk radio; 'she's going to knock off Harry Reid.' She was doing very well in some polls, but when it came down to Election Day, she got her clock cleaned. She's a weak candidate. Her background did not really present her with a lot of options in terms of campaigning and then she's going up against somebody who is one of the master candidates, who [has] been around forever and won repeatedly; who has the party apparatus at his fingertips. One of the things that we saw was you looked around at the candidates that were successful -- the tea party candidates -- and they were strong candidates anyway," Walling said.
Walling and Miller also have worked on a paper about what tea party members are doing now that they're in government. The lasting effect on the Senate side won't be known for a while, since they won't be facing re-election for another three years, Walling said.
"Whether they're being obstructionist for good depends on you, because if you oppose this president and you oppose things like immigration movement, then the obstruction is good. You think standing up and saying, 'We're going to block this.' Or Rand Paul's filibuster that he did where Ted Cruz came in the middle and read to his children so they could go to bed. All of that stuff to a supporter looked like 'go team,'" Walling said.
To the other side, it looked like "here we go again," Walling said.
Whether voters are on the left or right, policies passed in Congress have to include the median voter, so if that's true, it doesn't matter who the party outliers are, "the median is still going to be the median," Walling said.
"So you bring in Ted Cruz, or you bring in Rand Paul, or whoever else, they're still working over here in the fringes. The median's still going to be whoever that moderate Republican is from Maine," Walling said.
However, with an election like the Nov. 4 midterms, Walling said it does move the median voter to the right.
"We still haven't really seen anything come out of the tea party candidates that got elected in terms of product that they can point to and say, 'Our legacy is that. We did that,'" Walling said.
Pertinent address:
1 University Plaza, Cape Girardeau, Mo.
Haven’t seen a single riot at any tea party. No cities burned down.
Based on limited conversations (the DC 2010 event), I would say that Tea Party members aren’t exactly wealthy, but they’ve been logically frugal and didn’t buy houses they couldn’t afford. They didn’t buy cars beyond their pay scale. They didn’t take trips based on credit card debt. I’d even take a guess that most Tea Party enthusiasts have credit card debt of $5,000, or less.
Generally, they can’t understand the 30-year old who has moved back into house with mom and dad because of debt. They can’t understand why their local town has no real control over their budget. They can’t understand how a guy would owe $75,000 to several credit card companies.
It’s not that they are smarter....it’s just that they never got stupid and spent what they didn’t have.
Somehow, the fact that we have the worst possible man as president seems to not be a factor in the professor's examination.
My first TEA Party rally I ran into to people just like me.
High Intellect, well read, well educated many were six figure earners.
It was very comfortable and I don’t recall meeting a single overly impassioned idiot nor anyone who didn’t have an excellent grasp of the issues.
Didn’t matter what part of the income spectrum they fell on.
Just smart people and I’d celebrate 4th of July, Christmas and Easter with them anytime.
I’d celebrate Constitution Day with them as well but, that’s probably a bit of my narcissistic side, as it so happens to be my birthday...
If we ever do, it won’t be the real TEA Party, it’ll be ACORN, OWS, SEIU, AFSCME, OFA and the rest posing as the TEA Party.
We must have met the same people.
Just great.
Unlike my neighbors who have credit card bills that are astronomical, 2nd, 3rd and 4th mortgages and many that were consolidated under government subsidized loans.
Guess were they are now, two years later? In financial trouble again.
We are moving our assets to trusts and paying off mortgages in 9 years or less. Can’t be old and worried about any possibility of losing the properties.
Riots? Tea Partiers dont even litter.
There it is then, proof positive:
Empirical scientific evidence documenting that on average we FRiends are smarter and more successful—in sum, better—than DUmp dwellers.
We need our own country. If a Democrat wanders in, we’ll put him/her/them in the closest zoo, as we would any wild, exotic animal.
Like MENSA without so many nerds and goths.
Just the nicest people, who I would have been comfortable having lunch or dinner in my home.
That and they are just well informed on issues that can only be solved as a matter if math.
They, like me, wish people would get off their crosses.
The wood could be used for building useful things like homes or as firewood to heat the homes.
“Ohhhh but, life is so tuff! You don’t know what it’s like!!”
Really? I get the same 24 hours to live on the same rock and yeah, it’s tough. It’s meant to be.
It weeds out the weak.
Pussies.
I think that is a very good analysis.
The perfesser is surprised that people who are independent and thoughtful are better educated than the Obamaphone Kool aid drinkers? Really?
Conservative Leaders ‘Ganging Up’ To Oppose Jeb
http://radio.foxnews.com/2014/12/01/conservative-leaders-ganging-up-to-oppose-jeb/
Racist! /s
Not littering by TEA party is just the manifestation of white privilege by the patriarchy.
Or something.
All I know this AM is blacks screaming “kill whitey” while attacking two separate random white guys with hammers, and killing the second is not racism according to the St. Louis police.
They haven’t been sworn in yet, or did they forget that? They don’t just show up to work the next day! Wish they could, though!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.