Posted on 10/24/2014 8:09:13 AM PDT by Kaslin
Dear Kyle F. Student (not real name):
I am in receipt of your email request for extra credit. First of all, I would like to thank you for writing to ask for extra credit rather than wasting precious class time with your request. This will also spare you from being humiliated in front of your peers. Unfortunately, though, it will probably result in your being humiliated in front of numerous members of our community - some of whom will probably be members of our university community as well. Please allow me to explain.
Your extra credit assignment will be completed in five basic steps. In order to get full credit, you must complete each one of the following steps in order:
1. Buy a cardboard box and tear off a square piece approximately 12 inches wide and eight inches tall.
2. Purchase one black magic marker.
3. Using the black magic marker, write the following words on the piece of cardboard
ABLE-BODIED MAN REFUSES TO WORK
PLEASE GIVE ME SOMETHING I DID NOT EARN
4. Go to the Walmart on Market Street and College Road and hold up the sign at the entrance to the parking lot. Just blend right in with all the able-bodied men who are holding up signs begging for money instead of working. Stay there for approximately one hour.
5. Go home and write a 500 word description of what it felt like to ask people who work for a living to give you something you did not earn. I am especially interested in how it felt for you as a man to beg from women - especially those with small children in need of cheap food and modest clothing. Share your feelings with me, Kyle. And don’t hold back one bit. Pretend like you’re writing a Women’s Studies paper.
I predict that your reaction to this little assignment will take one of two forms. Each reaction requires a separate course of action and, therefore, must be discussed separately.
This would not be terribly surprising to me given your behavior this semester. Recall that you once asked the following question during a test review session: “Dr. Adams, what particular cases should we focus on (emphasis mine) as we prepare for the next exam?” In other words, you actually asked me which cases would be on the exam so that you could just read those – as opposed to all the cases you were assigned this semester.
Also, recall that after I specifically told you not to disclose personal medical information to me you came into my office and announced that you were “bi-polar.” In fact, you began your sentence by saying “I know we’re not supposed to tell you this, but …”
In other words, you seem to be more than just comfortable trying to get special treatment by making people feel sorry for you. In fact, you seem to feel entitled to beg for sympathy. And you would not do it unless you thought you could get something in the process.
In short, if you decide that you feel comfortable hanging out at Walmart with the other beggars then I would suggest that you drop out of college immediately. You don’t need a degree to hold a sign and look pathetic. Save yourself the debt, Kyle.
In fact, you might feel rightfully ashamed – knowing that you are able-bodied and can do much better with your God-given potential.
If your reaction is indeed one of shame then congratulations! The good news is that you will have earned ten points on your final average. The bad news is that it will have to be credited towards the ten points I just deducted from your average for asking me to give you something you did not earn.
Put simply, Kyle, there are two types of men in this world. There are those who spend their lives begging for things they don’t deserve. And then there are the rest of us who spend our lives working to subsidize their dependency. You simply need to decide what kind of man you are going to be.
Good luck on your assignment, Kyle. I look forward to reading your paper.
>> If a teacher actually did this they are a first rate jerk.
Mike Adams is not a jerk of any rate.
You certainly make a very good point there. I do not fault Adams for refusing extra credit. I fault him - greatly - for the sarcastic and humiliating way that he did it.
Some might see themselves in a mirror, but in a more candid form?
"He used.........sarcasm."
Some folks rank moralizing above everything that makes God who He is. I would say this holds true for the Christianized Adams.
So, yeah, the student is not without fault. But asking to do extra work for extra credit isn't ground for the tirade.
Perhaps. But as I mentioned in my post #22, my issue was with the humiliating way Adams turned down the request for extra credit. Students rarely learn anything of value when they are humiliated by a teacher.
The situation is somewhat different in the drill sergeant-recruit dynamic. But that's a different situation.
Wrong — now this is not an unrepentable sin, but wrong.
It's as good as any. Who knows, fast forward 20-30 years, when "Kyle" is a success, he may point to this as his wake-up call.
Seems to me Kyle needed to get out of Namby-Pamby Land.
Or it might have turned him away from God... taking this as what the visibly Christian Adams is really all about, and Adams will later have to answer to God why someone spent time in the wilderness who otherwise didn’t have to.
Funny how almost every situation in life can be related to either a Monty Python saying or a Seinfeld saying!
By the way, I wonder how many folks under 50 would have recognized your Monty Python reference there.
So I'm on Team Adams, having taught college students myself and having listened to some of the lamest excuses imaginable from slackers. Once in awhile, if the student actually had talent and potential, I went ahead and gave a D, and more than one of those gals then brought their performance up. If others left the program, good riddance and more time and energy available to the motivated students. In colleges, a lot of kids are taking up space on their parent's dime, wasting the opportunity and lowering the tone for the kids who are working two jobs to stay there. I have no patience for hand-holding with those sorts. And as I earlier noted, it sounds like Adams knew exactly what type of student he was dealing with.
It’s probably safe to assume this prof is not at a public university. Otherwise, they’d have him licking Kyle’s boots inside of an hour.
Which is why he anonymized the student and assigned a fictitious name. This way he gets to drive the point home and not publicly humiliate the student at the same time.
It will probably also serve to prevent future occurrences of students slacking off all semester and begging for extra credit assignments at the end to make up for it.
And sarcasm by definition is a low blow. Remember that Adams took on the mantle of Christ when he declared Christian faith.
Enrolling in a formal class and proceeding according to its preset plan is only one way to gain knowledge. Out of fairness to other students in the same class, the rules shouldn’t be bent except for bona fide emergencies, but perhaps things like tutoring and/or dropping the class to be re-enrolled in the future would help a student in difficulties pass in the future. None of this gets suggested as far as I see. There is more than one way to skin a cat.
the most rare of all species is the conservative college professor!!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.