[ilovesarah2012]

If it is unconstitutional to require photo ID to vote, it must be unconstitutional to require photo ID for everything.

[fhayek]

You need a photo ID for a pistol permit. Seems like it should be unconstitiutional too, using their logic.

[Rusty0604]

Maybe lots of people should file frivolous lawsuits when asking for ID for other things.

[pepsionice]

What I would suggest...is a national fake ID card, that we’d all just put a self-made JPG shot of ourselves next to a dog or cat, then print out the card and use it whenever required.

Now, saying this...for driving infractions....that’s different and a driver’s license would be mandatory (we’ve all read the state rule books and understand that concept). But beyond that...when at a drug store for prescription drugs, or entering an airport, or buying booze....we should pull out the fake national ID and insist on it being acceptable.

I think the Judge really said the right thing...we don’t need a photo ID for anything beyond driving responsibility. So, let’s all play the game desired.