Replies

My interpretation of the 10th is that states have final word on things not covered in the constitution which the Second is. Could states ban free speech?

But free speech is not an absolute right. Witness the "yelling fire in a crowded theater" and various "fighting word" restrictions.

Second Amendment rights are not absolute either. Some states restrict gun ownership by felons. Others do not. Some states deny concealed carry holders the right to take their weapon into jails or courtrooms. Others do not. Those kind of restrictions have not been found unconstitutional and I think those kinds of things should be a matter for the state to decide. The Supreme Court seemes to agree since in the Heller decision they basically said that state and local restrictions were not in and of themselves unconstitutional, just outright bans on gun ownership. So what New Jersey does in New Jersey's business. What Wyoming does is their own business as well.

Good grief! Not that old canard again. The saying is "you can't falsely (ie commit fraud, incite panic etc.) shout fire in a crowded theater. Similarly you can't hold up a liquor store with a gun. Neither situation has any bearing on your right to free speech or your right to keep and bear arms.

The Second Amendment and Yelling Fire in a Crowded Theatre

I thought that straw man had been put to bed on FR.

Second Amendment rights are not absolute either.

But isn't the question here whether or not the 2nd includes bearing arms outside the house. If this is a right per the 2nd then States can't say that right in itself is banned. We all have a stake in the outcome of this ruling so telling everyone else to butt out doesn't wash.