Posted on 02/06/2014 9:15:58 AM PST by cornelis
For most casual observers, whether Catholic or not, the main battle lines within American Catholicism today seem self-evident. The cleavage overlaps perfectly the divide between the political parties, leading to the frequently-used labels liberal and conservative Catholics. We have Nancy Pelosi and Andrew Cuomo representing the Left, and Rick Santorum and Sam Brownback aligned with the Right. Mainstream opinion has classified Popes John Paul II and Benedict XVI as honorary Republicans, and Pope Francis as a Democrat (hence, why he is appearing on the covers of Time and Rolling Stone Magazines).
This division does indeed capture real battle lines, but more than anything, the divide is merely an extension of our politics, andwhile manned by real actorsdoes not capture where the real action is to be found today in American Catholic circles.
The real action does not involve liberal Catholics at all. Liberal Catholicism, while well-represented in elite circles of the Democratic Party, qua Catholicism is finished. Liberal Catholicism has no futurelike liberal Protestantism, it is fated to become liberalism simpliciter within a generation. The children of liberal Catholics will either want their liberalism unvarnished by incense and holy water, or they will rebel and ask if theres something more challenging, disobeying their parents by reverting to Catholicism. While liberal Catholicism will appear to be a force because it will continue to have political representation, as a project and a theology, like liberal Protestantism it is doomed to oblivion.
The real battle is taking place beyond the purview of the pages of Time Magazine and the New York Times. The battle pits two camps of conservative Catholicism (lets dispense with that label immediately and permanentlyas my argument suggests, and others have said better, our political labels are inadequate to the task).
On the one side one finds . . .
(Excerpt) Read more at theamericanconservative.com ...
You are spot on. In reading this... could same not also be said about Liberal American Jews vs. Conservative Jews in Israel? Perhaps also same for traditional Protestant religions vs. liberal sects of same in America. Liberal lies have corrupted many, not just Catholics.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.