In the case of Israel we could actually get a lot closer to them. We could park a carrier group off their coast in the event they face a major attack. Just paying them to keep the carrier group supplied would amount to millions in trade. At the same time every smart governor in the country could lead trade missions to Israel to open up two way trade.
And along side that, most people forget the fact that most of the biggest tech and medical advances have come from Israel in recent years.
If America ever returns to being a friend of our allies.
Assuming Israel is willing to wait that long.