Could probably use a good face scrape...
I’ve got a good wire-brush to loan her. . .
Her skin is too aged to be heavily outlining her entire eye in that manner.
The lipstick color isn’t flattering to her aged face, either.
That lipstick color probably was good on her when she was 15-20 years younger.
She would probably be better off with a light gloss or a natural colored gloss. No eyeliner, just mascara on the lashes.