RE: "I think Paul Schiffer's proposed bill provides a defensible distinction for when to punish imports. If China is selling a native Chinese product, it is not fair to punish them exporting their products. But if they are building a US product in China [for export back to the U.S. that's not a Chinese product and therefore it can be hit with tariffs]."
You mean acknowledge what free trade really is -- what are you? Some kind of protectionist? :)