I am sorry, but this is still bugging me. Because we are right now with God where He is. I tried rather poorly above to explain. Will try again.
Most of what we know of God is from the Bible. We accept the Bible as the "Word of God". To my limited understanding there are a very few things that God is unable to do. Two that come to mind are sin and lie. In the Bible it says God is in all of Creation. With one glaring exception... Hell. That is what makes Hell, well hell. It's not the fire, or Brimstone, nor the torment of the fires of Gehenna. It is the ONLY place in all of Creation where God's Presence is not present. Those who deny God in life are granted just that in death. Destined to be in the only place in creation where God is not present, Hell.
Granted, sometimes it seems like this is hell, but it is not. 0bama has tried to transform the U.S. into hell but failed.