No, we’re not being too hard on him. He took an oath to uphold the Constitution - not uphold the reputation of the Court.
Why should Roberts care what the communists think of the court. It seems to me that the more the communists hate the court the better the job the court s doing!
I think the reputation of the Court is worse than it was before his reckless decision. Gay bath house photos?.. Ohhhh, never mind.