Compared to no one. His second term, save for Alito, was a tragedy beyond words.
He let the wars linger on end
He tried amnesty for illegals
He spent like crazy
He tried Dubai ports
He tried Harriet Meirs
He helped us lose the house and senate
He gave us Ben Bernake
He abdicated all financial responsibility his last two years
He allowed Paulsen to get way w TARP
YOU WANT MORE?
W WAS A DISASTER!
His first term was just as terrible. Free pills for granny, No Child Left Behind, Billions for AIDS in Africa and so forth.