This’ll be my final shot at this. I think the other poster is right, that you’re only sticking with this because you don’t see a way out.
You said the law applied only to aliens.
The law itself says it applies to people who are citizens at birth.
Therefore, you are arguing that people who are citizens at birth are also, at least at some point, aliens.
I have asked you what that point is.
You have answered only with rhetorical questions.
I conclude, therefore, that you don’t actually have an answer.
The law itself says it applies to people who are citizens at birth.
Where does the law say that? Can a law apply to a person who isn't born? How is that possible?
No, the law is applicable upon certain children at birth. It "applies to" alien parents.
The speed limit through a residential district is posted at 30 MPH.
Upon whom is the law applied to? Is it applicable upon another?
That's the point. You can't make a law on aliens and naturalization be about a person who was never an alien to begin with as their parent was.
The parent is the alien, not the child. The parent isn't the citizen, the child is when they're born and you can't enforce a law on someone before they're born (well, that goes into the whole abortion issue and just how wrong that law is).
The child has no choice but to be labeled a U.S. citizen.
The statute, makes them citizens at birth, absent the law, they'd be aliens. But a natural born citizen needs no law to be a citizen, they just are. The 14th amendment is, for this purpose, a law.